Cloth or disposable diaper?

While a generation of mothers eagerly embraced the disposable diaper, environmental concerns are prompting many moms today to return to cloth diapers.

So how to choose between the two? The reality is that many moms use both, some preferring disposable diapers for convenience when traveling with their baby, or at night for extra absorbency; and opting for cloth diaper during the day. Both have their pros and cons, and it’s worth taking the time to try out a few different types.

Cloth diapers

Today’s cloth diapers are very different to the terry diapers of old, and are made of lightweight, absorbent fabric that can be washed and dried very quickly. They can either be the all-in-one variety, or in three parts: a washable or disposable liner; the diaper itself, which may have poppers to fasten it; and a leakproof outer wrap fastened by Velcro or poppers. Get samples of a few designs in advance to see what suits you best.

While cloth diapers generally work out cheaper in the long run, the initial start-up cost is more as you’ll need up to 25 if you’re planning to use them full-time. If you’re put off by the idea of all that extra laundry, keep in mind that you can opt to use a diaper service – most provide an initial set of diapers, then pick up used diapers and provide clean diapers on a weekly basis for a fee. The National Association of Diaper Services has an online service locater at www.diapernet.org

Disposable diapers

Many moms find disposable diapers far more convenient, as they can simply be thrown away and don’t require washing and drying. There are a number of premium brands to choose from but own-brand options can be just as good as the more expensive ones. It’s always a good idea to sample a few before deciding on your preferred brand.

The disadvantage of disposable diapers is that they’re more harmful to the environment. Billions are disposed in landfill sites each year and some experts reckon they can take hundred of years to biodegrade.

Try not to feel too guilty about using disposables if it suits you and your baby. While babies are small they poop often and using cloth diapers may not be practical, especially if your baby is at daycare. If you’re a stay-at-home mom you might want to try cloth diapers once your baby gets bigger and is eating solids, since she’ll likely poop at fairly consistent times so you won’t get caught miles from home with a diaper that isn’t guaranteed to hold it all in!

The information in this feature is intended for educational purposes only. If you have any concerns about your health, the health of your child or the health of someone you know, please consult with a doctor or other healthcare professional.