Returning to work vs staying at home

Returning to work vs staying at home

Although previously you may have been an ambitious career woman, your number one priority will now be the little person who loves you – and whom you love – unconditionally.Many mums, however –whether it’s six months or five years down the line - will return to work, either through choice or through necessity. Others will opt to stay at home and be a full-time mum.

I was a stay-at-home mum until my daughter was four and since then I have worked full time for gurgle, as editorial assistant. Having been on both sides of the coin, I can give my honest opinion about the advantages and disadvantages of being both a stay-at-home and a working mum:

 

Benefits of being a stay-at-home mum:


*The main advantage is obviously that you can spend quality time with your children. You can spend the early days establishing a routine and really getting to know your little one. Once your child reaches nursery age, you can take him to nursery or pre-school and pick him up at the end of the day – something that working mums miss out on.

 

*You won’t feel the inevitable guilt that plagues so many working mums, who worry  that they are not seeing enough of their children.

 

*You will feel a sense of pride that you – and no one else – is bringing up your child and are responsible for the person who he or she will turn out to be. You are the one to praise your children when they are good and discipline them when they reach the terrible twos!

 

*The more time you spend with your child, the easier you may find it to bond with him.

 

*You will be there to witness those all-important milestones, from your child's wobbly first steps to his first word. As a working mum, there is a higher chance that you will miss out on these special events.

 

Disadvantages of being a stay-at-home mum:

*Some stay-at-home mums feel unfulfilled, and crave adult conversation and mental stimulation.

 

*Mums who don’t work also occasionally feel as if they are being looked down upon or as if their job of being a full-time mum isn’t recognised as worthy or credible.

 

*Although stay-at-home mums won’t feel the guilt of being apart from their children, they might feel guilty at not bringing in their own income.

 

*Some stay-at-home mums find that they lose their sense of identity; whereas before having children they might have been quite ambitious and career-driven, they may now view themselves solely as a mother.

 

*It can be a bit lonely being a stay-at-home, so it's important to make new mummy friends, whom you can meet up with on a regular basis. You can meet these friends at playgroups, toddler drop-in coffee mornings or even at the playground. It can be a bit scary putting yourself out there at first, but it's important to build up a network of friends to ensure you never feel isolated.


Pros of being a working mum:


*Some working mums would argue that they are setting a good example to their children, because they feel that they are encouraging them to go out and earn a living once they themselves become parents.

 

*Working mums often feel a certain sense of satisfaction at being able to ‘do it all’ – go out and work and also be a Mummy.

 

*Some working mums comment that they benefit from having ‘me time’ and that working helps them to rediscover a sense of identity; they aren’t just ‘Jack’s Mummy’, but Jill the teacher or Sarah the editor.

 

*Working mums also might gain satisfaction from being able to provide for their children from their own income. Being able to contribute financially to family life can also have a positive impact on your relationship with your husband or partner; the fact that you are both breadwinners can help you to feel equal.


*As a working mum, the time you have with your child is precious and you’re likely to really make the most of your weekends – you may appreciate your time with your little one even more so than if you were with him all day, every day.

Cons of being a working mum:


*As mentioned before, working mums more often than not feel great pangs of guilt at the time they spend away from their children. I can vouch for this! Although I love my job, I really miss my daughter and wish I could be there to take her to school and pick her up every day. If you do work full-time, you could check with your boss whether there's a possibility of working from home for one or more days; that way you can do the school pick-up on these days. I have one day working from home, and when I pick my daughter up from school her face really lights up! Trust me, it makes all the difference.

 

*If you're out at work all day, there's a chance you may miss out on important milestones, such as the first time your baby crawls or says his first word.

 

*You have to put up with the fact that your child may sometimes ask for his nanny or even call you by the nanny’s name – a real heart-wrencher!

 

*Your child will also often lay guilt trips on you, so you have to be prepared for this: ‘Why do you have to work, Mummy?’ – (‘To keep you in chocolate buttons!’) or ‘I wish you could pick me up from school.’


 

*You often feel that you haven’t quite got the balance right and that you’re always spreading yourself a bit too thinly. This is increasingly likely if you are working full-time, rather than part-time. At the end of a long day at work, when you’ve put the kids to bed and are sitting down for a quick bite with your hubby before collapsing into bed, you may feel as if you haven’t had time fully to dedicate yourself to either your job or your child.

 

*Some working mums keep their children up a bit later at night than they would otherwise -I'm guilty of this! - so that they can spend time with them after work. The problem with this is that your child is more likely to be tired and grumpy, which can then lead to you being a bit snappy and irritable.

 

Don't beat yourself up!

At the end of the day, it's a completely personal decision as to whether you decide to stay at home or return to work (and your decision will often be based on factors such as whether you can afford not to work). The important thing is that both you and your little one are happy; you should never be made to feel guilty if you do work, or belittled if you don't! Ultimately, we are all our harshest critics and we mums should give ourselves a break. No-one's perfect and there's no 'ideal' situation; it's simply a case of working out what's right for you and your family.

 

Discover what your baby will cost with gurgle's Baby Budget Calculator

See all our Baby Budget features

 

If you'd like to chat to other mums about whether they decided to stay at home or return to work, why not talk to them in the Work area of our chat forum? Or you could create your own group about your experiences of being either a working mum or a stay-at-home mum.

 

The information in this feature is intended for educational purposes only. If you have any concerns about your health, the health of your child or the health of someone you know, please consult with a doctor or other healthcare professional.

Last Modified:

Advertisement

Comments

By yummymum9 8 months ago Newbie Lucky ChatPRO News
I would love to have been able to be a stay at home mama but unfortunatly we just cant afford it! I do 3 days a week and lo goes to a private nursary two mornings, mil two afternoons and my parents 1 full day. We are so lucky to have the help from the Grandparents as we just wouldnt be able to afford to pay for more childcare. It hurts to leave lo at nursary some mornings when he says he doesnt want to go but he does enjoy it when he is there and when he is off he asks if he is going! It stimulates him and he likes to play with his little mates. I feel that people judge me for working, like they love their children more because they stay at home with theirs.

I have friends that stay at home and moan that they have so much house work to do and I want to shout so have I on top of work!! It is very hard being a part time working mama as I still have domestic duties and most nights I dont sit down until 10.30 pm. Me and OH have always shared chores but as he works full time I do put alot of pressure on myself to do more than my share as I feel guilty for having more time with the lo.

If you can afford to stay at home do it but please appreciate it. It was a real shock for me to have to leave lo for the very first time at 9 months old to go to work. I love being a Mama and truely wish we could manage on one wage.

Sorry for the essay......just read over it, why do us mamas carry all this guilt around? Are we our own worst critics?
we are DEFINATLY our own worst critics! we feel bad if we stay home and money is tight and bad if we work and dont get to c LO! think it should be about personnel choice dont think either role is easy as stay at home mummies can often feel isolated/lonley. love being at home weoth LOS but can be hard. :) xxxx
By yummymum9 8 months ago Newbie Lucky ChatPRO News
im a stay at home mummy too and am hoping to be for as long as possible. would love to be home till youngest is starting secondryt school then go back part time as child care by us is SSSSSSSOOOO expensive (bet its no more expensive than where you ladies are so you know what i mean! for 3 LOs it would be about £630 a week for 35 hours a week each!!!!) i also want be ther for sports days and school plays etc. if it got to the stage we couldnt affford to live i would happily go back to work although dont thing we would be much better off. anyhoo lol sahm's should be recognised as working! we work bloody hard :) (would like to say i also have a MASSIVE MASSIVE admiration for working mummies :) xxxx
By Mama Moomin 8 months ago Newbie ChatPRO News
tbh if u can afford to stay at home then go for it!! ive been a sahm for 4 years-my little man has started reception this week. i plan on being with my 21 month old until he goes to school too-it really is a wonderful experience. a lot of my friends would give anything to be able to stay at home with their children but just can't afford it.

ive had a few people comment on 'being unemployed' but actually raising children IS MY JOB!! haha also im a wedding photographer at weekends-so i dont miss being with the boys.

GL and honestly do what feels right for u-dont worry about what other people think.
By Serens_Mummy 8 months ago Newbie Lucky ChatPRO News LikePRO
It really does depend on circumstance I really would like to be a stay at home mum but the fact is we can't afford it. Not like we'd go without luxuries more like we'd starve, so am going back to work as a care assistant so I can work a full week in fewer days which means 2-3 days in nursery for Seren meaning I see her more and it cuts my childcare costs. I was a HR admin but the childcare costs are so big and I have no family that can help my mum and sis both work and Seren's granddads are useless one's a drunk and the other has never seen her, it wouldn't be worth me going back to that. You shouldn't feel guilty for going back to work if you have to though because your setting a good example for your kids that work is a good thing and that supporting yourself and your family is the way to go xxx
By onewynne 8 months ago Newbie Lucky ChatPRO
I have no choice i have to work otherwise we would be out on the streets! I would love to be a stay at home mum but that is just not an option :-(
By mamaoftwo 1 years ago Newbie Lucky Superstar
i loooooove bein an at home mum, the reason i had kids was to spend time with them, love them, bring them up! i love my home to and love to make sure dinner is ready n on table for wen jamie comes home! once my kids go to school yes i will work, but pt as i want to b able to have time to keep the house tidy and b a proper family which is something i never had! i believe if worked full time it wld put 2 much pressure on the family, jamie works full time, so if i wet pt i can still do my home jobs and b there for if the kids have time off school for being ill! i love wkends which is y i wont work wkends as its family time! theres far to much pressure on familys which is prob y alot of family do break up which is sad! i love my family they come 1st and always will xxxx
LIKE!!!! i had my lovely children and i want to bring them up too.xxx
By LucyRuth 1 years ago Newbie Lucky Superstar
i loooooove bein an at home mum, the reason i had kids was to spend time with them, love them, bring them up! i love my home to and love to make sure dinner is ready n on table for wen jamie comes home! once my kids go to school yes i will work, but pt as i want to b able to have time to keep the house tidy and b a proper family which is something i never had! i believe if worked full time it wld put 2 much pressure on the family, jamie works full time, so if i wet pt i can still do my home jobs and b there for if the kids have time off school for being ill! i love wkends which is y i wont work wkends as its family time! theres far to much pressure on familys which is prob y alot of family do break up which is sad! i love my family they come 1st and always will xxxx
LIKE! Very true about family pressures these days. Though maybe if you see your kids and OH less you have less time to argue with them?!
By harley16 1 years ago Newbie Lucky ChatPRO News LikePRO
i loooooove bein an at home mum, the reason i had kids was to spend time with them, love them, bring them up! i love my home to and love to make sure dinner is ready n on table for wen jamie comes home! once my kids go to school yes i will work, but pt as i want to b able to have time to keep the house tidy and b a proper family which is something i never had! i believe if worked full time it wld put 2 much pressure on the family, jamie works full time, so if i wet pt i can still do my home jobs and b there for if the kids have time off school for being ill! i love wkends which is y i wont work wkends as its family time! theres far to much pressure on familys which is prob y alot of family do break up which is sad! i love my family they come 1st and always will xxxx
By princessldf 1 years ago Newbie Lucky ChatPRO News Like
I like being a full time mum, Riley and me are really close, he's a proper mummy's boy...but...I do have to say I'm thinking about putting him into nursery for a couple of hours a week, he does get to play with other kids, but I'd like him to have like more kids to play with. I think my OH prefers me staying home as well, and now this LO is on it's way I probably won't be going to work until this baby is 3. x
By SarahFarley 1 years ago Newbie Lucky Chat
I think it all depends on the situation, we chose to have kids because we both have steady jobs an earn enough money for our life style. I am going back to work in 4 months an both my kids will be in child care/with Grandma. I couldn't justify giving up work at the moment and I like the fact my kids get to socialise with other people an other kids. I think it's harsh to say parents who work full time miss out on special moments with there kids, I have been with my LO's when they have done something new as I spend all my time at home interacting with them. It's tiring but it's worth it coz I know I can give them what they need with us both working.
Why not join in this chat? It only takes a few moments to login or register..
Login or Register

Shortcuts

 
Nominate your favourite products and blogs in the gurgles 2012!
x