My daughter is coming up three and still has her 'magic' ('cos it's magic) when she's upset and bedtime. We discovered that the darker coloured ones are easier for us and her to find in the low light of the night light. Now she sorts herself out and we get some glorious sleep. There are others available which glow in the dark but they're quite expensive, try a larger boots chemist, I'm sure you'll find them there. You could also try putting her thumb in instead as she's still very young. They adapt better at that age, and it will probably only take one sleepless night to adjust. Good luck!
Hi
My daughter has just started to do the same. Has anyone found an answer in the last year?
my son is 5 months old also and he is just the same. i usually find it helps t wait till there in a deep sleep and take it out.